Skid Steer vs. Compact Track Loader: Which is Right For You?
So, you’re shopping for a heavy-lifting workhorse that can get the job done. You’ve narrowed it down to a skid steer and a compact track loader, but which John Deere machine is right for your needs? Although the two terms are often used interchangeably, there are a few key features to help decide which machine is right for you. Here, we’ll break down all the most important factors for making your decision including budget, tasks, and terrain.
A Quick Comparison
At first glance, skid steers and track loaders look similar: both are compact machines designed to deliver high performance on heavy-lifting tasks. Both pieces of equipment excel in different areas–here’s a quick look:
A Closer Look
Skid Steer
The Pros
The Cons
Compact Track Loader
The Pros
The Cons
Contact One of Our Experts
At Shoppa’s, we’re here to help get your hands on the equipment you need to get the job done. Call or visit your local Shoppa’s Farm Supply to discuss the demands of your work, and we’ll get you set up with the perfect piece of equipment for your needs.
-
Skid steers are preferable in urban environments and construction areas where work surfaces are harder, like concrete, asphalt, etc. Skid steers also typically come at a lower cost, and are cheaper to maintain.
-
Compact track loaders, on the other hand, perform excellently on softer grounds and in wetter conditions. Where ground impact is important, the larger surface area of the track loader makes it the better choice.
-
Fast and maneuverable. Skid steers excel in tight spaces like urban areas and indoor work.
-
Efficient on hard surfaces. The four wheels provide a smoother and faster ride than you'll experience on a track loader.
-
Skid steers have fewer complex components, making them cheaper and easier to maintain.
-
Poor traction on wet, loose, and rough terrain. Their weight isn't as evenly distributed as track loaders, sometimes leading them to sink in poor off-road conditions.
-
Less stability on slopes and uneven terrain.
-
Improved stability. The larger footprint of the track makes for a smoother ride on sloped terrains. As a bonus, the greater stability makes for a higher lift capacity.
-
Tracks perform especially well in wetter and softer conditions, making them the best choice for off-road conditions.
-
Reduced ground pressure. The larger footprint of the compact track loader reduces unwanted ground pressure, compaction and erosion.
-
The track system is complex, making track loaders more expensive and more difficult to maintain. This could lead to increased downtime.
-
Tracks perform less efficiently on harder surfaces like concrete, asphalt, etc.
